This site contains affiliate links. View the disclosure for more information.
New to benefits admin? Don’t panic. Here’s your no-BS survival guide that won’t put you to sleep.
Okay, let’s start with the brutal truth: you just got handed benefits administration, and suddenly everyone’s throwing around acronyms like confetti at a retirement party. ACA! ERISA! COBRA! MHPAEA!
You’re probably thinking, “Great, I went to school for HR, not alphabet soup interpretation.”
Here’s what nobody tells new benefits admins: everyone feels overwhelmed at first. Even the “experts” who’ve been doing this for years still Google “COBRA notice requirements” sometimes. The difference? They’ve learned which stuff actually matters and which stuff is just regulatory noise.
2025 is bringing some real changes that you need to know about. The Department of Labor is cracking down harder than ever. Mental health compliance is the new hot topic. And yes, the penalties are scary enough to make your CFO cry.
But here’s the good news: you don’t need a law degree to master this stuff. You just need someone to translate the legal mumbo-jumbo into plain English and tell you exactly what to do (and when to do it).
That’s what we’re doing here. No boring compliance lectures. No overwhelming legal jargon. Just the real-world, practical stuff that’ll keep you out of trouble and help you sleep at night.
Ready to turn that compliance panic into confidence? Let’s go.
Why This Stuff Actually Matters (And Why Your Boss Cares)
Look, I get it. Compliance feels like the least fun part of benefits admin. You’d rather be helping employees understand their health plans or planning that wellness program everyone’s excited about.
But here’s why compliance should be at the top of your priority list: the penalties are absolutely bonkers.
Real Talk: The Government Is Serious About This
The Department of Labor did over 1,400 benefit plan audits last year and collected $1.4 billion—that’s billion with a B—in penalties and corrections. They’re not auditing the Fortune 500 companies with armies of lawyers. They’re coming for mid-sized employers like yours who might not have their compliance ducks in a row.
Translation: If you think you’re too small to get noticed, think again.
Mental Health Compliance Is the New Big Thing
Remember when everyone was freaking out about ACA compliance back in 2014? Mental health parity is having that same moment right now. Employee lawsuits around mental health coverage violations have tripled since 2022, according to BenefitsPro tracking data.
Here’s what’s happening: employees are getting smarter about their rights. They’re noticing when their mental health benefits are harder to access than their regular medical benefits. And they’re not just complaining—they’re suing.
Your Employees Are Asking Harder Questions
Gone are the days when you could hand someone a 40-page benefits booklet and call it good. Today’s employees want to know:
- Why does my therapist need prior authorization but my cardiologist doesn’t?
- How many mental health providers are actually in-network in my area?
- Why is my mental health copay different from my regular doctor visits?
If you can’t answer these questions, you’ve got a compliance problem and an employee relations problem.
The Bottom Line
Benefits compliance isn’t just about avoiding penalties (though those are scary enough). It’s about building trust with your employees and protecting your company’s reputation. Get this right, and you become the HR hero who keeps everyone safe and happy. Get it wrong, and… well, let’s focus on getting it right.
The Compliance Landmines That’ll Blow Up Your Day
Alright, let’s talk about the stuff that’s most likely to get you in trouble. These are the compliance areas where even experienced benefits admins stumble—so don’t feel bad if some of this is news to you.
Mental Health Parity: The Compliance Monster Everyone’s Talking About
Here’s the deal: if your health plan covers mental health services (and most do), those benefits have to be just as good as your regular medical benefits. Sounds simple, right?
Wrong. It’s way more complicated than it sounds.
You have to prove that your mental health coverage isn’t more restrictive than medical coverage in four different areas:
- Financial stuff (deductibles, copays, coinsurance)
- Treatment limits (visit limits, day/lifetime maximums)
- Prior authorization (approval requirements)
- Network access (how many providers are available)
Most companies fail on network access. They’ll have 200 cardiologists in-network but only 12 therapists. That’s a violation, even if the copays are the same.
The scary part? You need to document all of this in writing and make it available to employees who ask for it. No documentation = automatic violation when the DOL comes knocking.
Form 5500: The Annual Nightmare That Trips Everyone Up
If you have a health plan, retirement plan, or other employee benefits with 100+ participants, you have to file Form 5500 every year. Due date: July 31st (or October 15th if you file an extension).
Sounds straightforward, right? Here’s where it gets tricky:
- File late? $250 per day in penalties. That’s $91,250 per year if you just… forget.
- Wrong participant count? Penalty plus potential audit.
- Missing required schedules? More penalties.
- Forgot to get an audit for your large plan? Even bigger penalties.
Real story: A company with 500 employees filed their Form 5500 three months late and got hit with a $22,500 penalty. For filing paperwork late. That’s someone’s salary.
ERISA Documents: The Paperwork That Actually Matters
Your Summary Plan Description (SPD) isn’t just a fancy brochure. It’s a legal contract. If your SPD says something, you have to honor it—even if it was a mistake.
Common SPD disasters:
- Saying coverage starts “immediately” when it actually starts after 30 days
- Describing benefits that don’t match your actual insurance contract
- Forgetting to update SPDs when you change plans (required within 60 days)
Then there are “wrap documents”—don’t worry, they’re not as complicated as they sound. They’re basically the legal documents that turn your insurance certificates into official ERISA plans. Many companies either don’t have them or have ones that don’t match reality.
ACA Affordability: The Math Problem That Never Goes Away
If you’re a large employer (50+ full-time employees), you have to offer “affordable” health coverage. For 2025, that means coverage can’t cost more than 9.02% of an employee’s household income.
Plot twist: You don’t know your employees’ household income. So you use “safe harbors”—basically, approved ways to calculate affordability without knowing everyone’s personal finances.
Get it wrong, and you could owe $4,460 per full-time employee (minus the first 30) in penalties. For a 200-employee company, that’s over $750,000 in potential penalties.
COBRA: The “Simple” Process That Isn’t
COBRA seems straightforward: when someone loses coverage, give them the option to keep it by paying the full premium. Easy, right?
Nope. The timeline requirements are brutal:
- You have 30 days to notify your COBRA administrator after a qualifying event
- They have 14 days to send the election notice to the employee
- Employee has 60 days to elect COBRA
- First payment is due within 45 days of election
Miss any of these deadlines, and you’re looking at $110 per day per affected person in penalties, plus potential lawsuit damages.
The kicker? Most COBRA violations happen because a manager didn’t tell HR about a qualifying event quickly enough. Your compliance is only as strong as your weakest-trained supervisor.
Your “I Don’t Want to Get Fired” Action Plan
Okay, enough with the scary stuff. Let’s talk solutions. Here’s how to build a compliance system that actually works without taking over your entire life.
Step 1: Build a Calendar That Saves Your Butt
Forget those overwhelming compliance spreadsheets that make your eyes glaze over. You need a system that actually reminds you when stuff is due.
Here’s what works:
Set up four seasonal check-ins:
- Winter (Jan-Mar): ACA reporting, document updates, mental health analysis
- Spring (Apr-Jun): Form 5500 prep and filing, vendor reviews
- Summer (Jul-Sep): Mid-year health check, open enrollment prep
- Fall (Oct-Dec): Year-end prep, planning for next year
Use whatever calendar system you already love—Google Calendar, Outlook, Asana, whatever. The key is putting everything in ONE place and setting up automatic reminders.
Pro tip: Set reminders for 30 days AND 7 days before each deadline. Trust me on this.
Step 2: Make Technology Do the Heavy Lifting
You know what’s worse than compliance? Doing compliance manually when computers could handle it for you.
If you’re still tracking COBRA elections in Excel or sending out SPDs via interoffice mail, we need to talk. Benefits administration platforms like COBRA Admin or HR Admin can automate:
- COBRA notice distribution and tracking
- SPD updates and distribution
- Form 5500 data collection
- ACA reporting preparation
Yes, these systems cost money. You know what costs more? Compliance violations.
Step 3: Train Your Managers (They’re Your Secret Weapons)
Here’s something nobody tells new benefits admins: your biggest compliance risks aren’t in your benefits office. They’re out there with your managers who don’t understand their role in benefits compliance.
A supervisor who doesn’t report a divorce quickly enough can trigger COBRA violations. A manager who handles a leave request wrong can create ACA reporting problems.
Solution: Monthly “Compliance Coffee Chats” with managers. Keep them short (15 minutes max) and focus on real scenarios:
- “Sarah’s getting divorced. What do you do?”
- “Mike’s asking about therapy coverage. How do you respond?”
- “Jennifer’s going on maternity leave. What’s your role?”
Make it practical, not preachy.
Step 4: Document Everything (Future You Will Send Thank-You Cards)
During a DOL audit, your documentation isn’t just helpful—it’s everything. Start building your “compliance story” now:
When you make benefits changes, document why. When you update mental health coverage, save the analysis you did. When employees ask questions, keep records of your responses.
Use a shared drive system like SharePoint or Google Drive that your whole team can access. Create folders by topic (Mental Health Parity, COBRA, ACA) so you can find stuff quickly.
The goal isn’t to become a paperwork hoarder. It’s to show regulators that you take compliance seriously and have systems to prove it.
Step 5: Make Your Vendors Actually Help You
Your benefits broker or TPA should be your compliance partner, not just someone who sells you stuff and disappears. If your current vendor can’t answer compliance questions or help you stay on top of deadlines, it’s time to find one who can.
Set up monthly check-ins with your broker specifically about compliance. Create a shared dashboard that tracks your key deadlines and requirements. Make them earn their commission by actually helping you succeed.
Your Foolproof 2025 Compliance Calendar
Now that you have your system in place, you need to know exactly when to do what. This is where a lot of benefits admins get overwhelmed—there are deadlines scattered throughout the year, and it’s easy to lose track of what’s due when.
I’ve taken all the guesswork out of it for you. Below is your month-by-month roadmap that tells you exactly what to focus on and when. You don’t have to memorize this whole thing—just bookmark it and check back each month to see what’s on your plate.
The best part? This calendar is designed to spread your compliance work evenly throughout the year. No more scrambling in July to file forms you should have started preparing in April. No more realizing in December that you forgot to do your mental health parity analysis.
Here’s how to use this: at the beginning of each month, look at that month’s priorities and add them to your regular calendar. Set reminders. Make them as important as any other business deadline, because they are.
JANUARY – New Year, New Compliance
- The Big One: File ACA Forms 1094-C and 1095-C (due Jan 31 for paper, March 31 for electronic)
- Do This Too: Update your affordability calculations with new federal poverty guidelines
- Don’t Forget: Schedule your Q1 compliance review meetings
- Pro Tip: This is also a great time to clean up your employee data and fix any classification issues from last year
FEBRUARY – Document Detective Month
- Review Time: Pull out all your Summary Plan Descriptions and read them like you’re a new employee
- Check This: Do your SPDs match what you actually offer? If not, update them
- Mental Health Focus: Start your annual mental health parity analysis (you’ll thank yourself later)
- Manager Training: Perfect time for your first compliance coffee chat of the year
MARCH – Spring Cleaning for Benefits
- Wrap It Up: Review your ERISA wrap documents (yes, they need to be accurate too)
- COBRA Check: Audit your COBRA processes—are notices going out on time?
- Vendor Review: How did your vendors perform last year? Time for honest conversations
- Documentation: Start organizing files for Form 5500 season
APRIL – Form 5500 Prep Begins
- Data Collection: Start gathering participant counts, financial info, and plan details
- Audit Alert: If you need a plan audit, schedule it now (don’t wait until July!)
- Insurance Review: Check your fiduciary liability insurance—does it cover current plan assets?
- Training Time: Second quarter compliance coffee chat with managers
MAY – The Steady Month
- 5500 Continued: Keep working on those forms (seriously, don’t procrastinate)
- Mental Health: Finish that parity analysis you started in February
- Policy Updates: Review and update any benefits policies that need refreshing
- Network Check: How’s your mental health provider network looking? Now’s the time to fix problems
JUNE – Almost There
- Final Push: Complete Form 5500 preparation
- Double Check: Review all filings before submission (trust but verify)
- Mid-Year Review: How’s your compliance going so far? What needs attention?
- Open Enrollment Prep: Yes, it’s early, but start thinking about fall changes
JULY – Filing Frenzy
- The Deadline: Form 5500s are due July 31st (or file an extension for October 15th)
- ACA Mid-Year: Conduct your mid-year ACA compliance check
- Breathe: You’re halfway through the year and doing great
- Plan Ahead: Start open enrollment compliance preparation
AUGUST – Open Enrollment Prep
- Document Review: Make sure all plan documents are ready for open enrollment
- Communication Audit: Are your employee materials compliant and accurate?
- Manager Training: Third quarter compliance coffee chat (they need refreshers too)
- System Check: Test your benefits administration system before the rush
SEPTEMBER – Getting Ready for Go-Time
- Final Prep: Last chance to fix any open enrollment compliance issues
- Mental Health Disclosures: Prepare any required parity disclosures for employees
- Training Intensive: Make sure everyone knows their open enrollment compliance roles
- Vendor Coordination: Confirm all vendors are ready for open enrollment
OCTOBER – Open Enrollment Season
- Go Live: Execute your compliant open enrollment process
- Document Everything: Keep records of all employee communications and elections
- Daily Monitoring: Watch for any compliance issues that pop up during enrollment
- ACA Planning: Start calculating affordability for next year
NOVEMBER – Wrapping Up OE
- Final Elections: Process all open enrollment elections compliantly
- Year-End Planning: Begin ACA reporting preparation for next year
- Vendor Reviews: How did everyone perform during open enrollment?
- Documentation: Organize all your open enrollment compliance records
DECEMBER – Year-End Victory Lap
- Next Year Planning: Update your compliance calendar for 2026
- Budget Time: Plan your compliance budget for next year
- Risk Assessment: What are your biggest compliance risks going into next year?
- Celebrate: You made it through your first year! (Or another successful year!)
Your Weekly Routine (Keep It Simple):
- Monday: Check compliance calendar and weekly priorities
- Wednesday: Vendor check-ins and issue resolution
- Friday: Review week’s compliance activities and prep for next week
Emergency Backup Plan:
- Always have a backup person who knows your critical deadlines
- Keep an “emergency compliance contact list” with your lawyer, broker, and key vendors
- Know where all your important documents are stored
- Have a “compliance crisis plan” for when things go wrong
Remember: This calendar isn’t meant to overwhelm you. Start with the deadlines that apply to your current situation, and build from there. The key is consistency—small, regular actions throughout the year prevent those panic-inducing compliance emergencies.
You’ve Got This (Seriously)
Look, I know this feels like a lot. When I first started in benefits admin, I spent way too many nights lying awake wondering if I’d forgotten some critical deadline or missed some important requirement.
But here’s what I learned: benefits compliance isn’t about being perfect. It’s about being prepared, staying organized, and building systems that catch problems before they become disasters.
You don’t need to become a compliance expert overnight. You just need to start where you are, with what you have, and build from there. Pick one thing from this guide—maybe it’s setting up that compliance calendar, or finally tackling your mental health parity analysis—and just start.
The benefits admins who succeed aren’t the ones who never make mistakes. They’re the ones who learn from their mistakes, build better systems, and help their companies stay compliant while actually helping employees get the benefits they need.
Ready to stop worrying and start succeeding? Download our free “New Benefits Admin Survival Kit”—it includes template compliance calendars, manager training scripts, and a quick-reference guide for all the acronyms that are making your head spin. Plus, you’ll get our weekly newsletter with tips, updates, and real-world advice from benefits admins who’ve been exactly where you are right now.
Get Your Free Survival Kit Here and join thousands of benefits admins who’ve turned compliance from their biggest stress into their biggest strength.
Because benefits administration should be about helping people, not losing sleep over regulations.
Questions? Panic attacks? Need someone to explain what a “wrap document” actually is? We’ve been there. Drop us a line—we love helping new benefits admins figure out this crazy, rewarding field. You’re not alone in this.
This site contains affiliate links. View the disclosure for more information.
